Skip to content

Who Was on the Cross Next to Jesus? Revealing the Penitent Thief!

Who Was on the Cross Next to Jesus?

Ever wondered who barabbas hung on that cross beside Jesus? The identity of this mysterious figure from the gospels has captivated scholars for centuries. Historical accounts offer intriguing clues about their background and significance, shedding light on a lesser-known character from the new testament. Matthew, John, Luke, and Mark each provide their own unique perspective on this pivotal moment in the bible. Picture the scene: a bustling crowd, heads turning in disbelief as two figures are crucified side by side. But who was this person? What led barabbas to share such a fateful place with Jesus? Delving into this enigma not only unravels an age-old question but also reveals surprising insights into the events that unfolded that day. Join us as we embark on an exploration of this captivating tale, where names intertwine and destinies collide beneath a single crossbar.

Identifying the Crucified Individuals: Dismas and Gestas

The crucifixion of Jesus, as depicted in the gospels of the New Testament, is a significant event in Christian history. It is often shown with two other individuals, Dismas and Gestas, being crucified alongside him. These individuals play important roles in the narrative surrounding Jesus’ crucifixion on the crossbar.

Dismas: The Good Thief

One of the individuals crucified next to Jesus, known as Dismas, is often called the “Good Thief” or “Penitent Thief.” In Luke 23:39-43, Dismas acknowledges his wrongdoing and seeks forgiveness from Jesus. He says, “Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom,” and Jesus responds, “Truly I tell you, today you will be with me in paradise.

Dismas, also known as the good thief, represents a powerful symbol of redemption and repentance in the gospels. Despite his past transgressions, he recognizes Jesus’ divinity and expresses genuine remorse for his actions. This portrayal serves as a testament to the transformative power of faith and demonstrates that even those deemed unworthy, like Barabbas, can find salvation.

Gestas: The Bad Thief

In contrast to Dismas’ penitent nature, the other individual crucified alongside Jesus, known as Gestas or the “Bad Thief” or “Impenitent Thief,” does not express remorse or seek forgiveness for his sins. Instead, he mocks Jesus along with others who pass by. This depiction aligns with the gospel accounts in Matthew 27:44, John, and Luke.

Gestas, the good thief, represents an unrepentant character who symbolizes stubbornness and resistance towards redemption. His refusal to acknowledge his wrongdoing, despite being given the opportunity for forgiveness, highlights an important moral lesson within the crucifixion narrative. The presence of Gestas, along with Barabbas and the insurrection, serves as a reminder that salvation requires genuine contrition and a willingness to accept forgiveness. This narrative can be found in the book of Matthew.

The identification of Dismas and Gestas, also known as the good thief and Barabbas, as the individuals on the crosses next to Jesus has been passed down through Christian tradition. However, it is important to note that their names are not explicitly mentioned in the Gospels of John and Luke. Instead, their identities have been established through various historical sources and interpretations.

Early church fathers such as Tertullian, Origen, and Augustine have contributed to our understanding of figures like Barabbas, the good thief, John, and Luke. Ancient texts like the Gospel of Nicodemus provide further insights into their roles during Jesus’ crucifixion. These sources help solidify the traditional identification of Dismas and Gestas.

Contrasting Beliefs: Penitent vs. Impenitent Thief

Dismas, the Penitent Thief

Dismas, also known as the penitent thief or the good thief, stood next to Jesus on the cross. He recognized his own wrongdoing and sought redemption. In a display of humility and faith, Dismas turned towards Jesus and asked for forgiveness. This encounter with Jesus took place at Golgotha, the hill where Barabbas was released and John the Baptist was beheaded. The significance of this moment is captured in the story of Dismas, who ultimately found paradise through his repentance. Today, we can find inspiration in Dismas’ transformation and remember that even the most unlikely individuals can find redemption in the church.

In his final moments, Dismas, the good thief, uttered words that revealed his repentant heart. He recognized Jesus’ innocence and openly admitted his own guilt. With sincerity in his voice, he asked Jesus to remember him when He entered His kingdom, the paradise. This plea demonstrated Dismas’ belief in Jesus’ divinity and power to grant salvation. It was a powerful moment in the presence of John and the church.

Dismas, a good thief, serves as an inspiring example of redemption. Despite a life of crime, he found forgiveness from Jesus at the church. This act showcases the transformative power of faith and Christ’s boundless mercy.

Gestas, the Impenitent Thief

In direct contrast to Dismas, the good thief, John’s brother Gestas chose a path of defiance and mockery while hanging on the cross beside Jesus in the church. Rather than acknowledging any wrongdoing or expressing remorse for his crimes, Gestas opted to join those who taunted Jesus during His crucifixion.

Gestas, the good thief, hurled insults at Jesus without hesitation, mocking Him alongside others who failed to recognize His true identity. In this moment of suffering and judgment, John, a member of the church, witnessed Gestas showing no signs of regret or desire for redemption. Instead, he hardened his heart against any possibility of change or salvation. To learn more about the free Saint Dismas prayer card, visit our website.

The impenitent attitude displayed by Gestas, the bad thief, serves as a cautionary tale about rejecting opportunities for transformation and forgiveness. It reveals how John, the good thief’s brother, chose a different path. By acknowledging his mistakes and seeking redemption, John received God’s grace and was set free. To honor Saint Dismas, you can get a free prayer card.

Contrasting Responses to Jesus’ Presence on the Cross

The stark contrast between Dismas, the good thief, and Gestas highlights the divergent responses individuals can have when confronted with Jesus’ presence, even in the midst of their own suffering. While Dismas, John’s brother, recognized his need for salvation and humbly sought forgiveness, Gestas remained defiant and unrepentant.

This juxtaposition presents a powerful lesson about the choices John and we make in our lives. It prompts us to reflect on how we respond to moments of crisis or encounters with John’s teachings. Will we embrace humility, acknowledge our faults, and seek redemption? Or will we stubbornly cling to our pride and reject opportunities for transformation with John?

The story of John and the penitent and impenitent thieves challenges us to examine our own beliefs and actions. It reminds us that it is never too late to turn towards Jesus, regardless of our past mistakes or current circumstances. Just as John found hope amidst his darkest hour, we too can find solace in His unconditional love and offer of redemption.

Profound Encounter: The Criminals’ Experience with Jesus

During the crucifixion of Jesus, two criminals were also nailed to crosses on either side of him. This unexpected encounter would prove to be a pivotal moment for both thieves, as they had the opportunity to witness firsthand the divinity and innocence of Jesus Christ.

Dismas recognized Jesus’ innocence and divinity, leading him to seek forgiveness.

One of the criminals, known as Dismas, began to recognize that there was something unique about Jesus. Perhaps it was the way he carried himself amidst unimaginable suffering or the profound words he spoke even in his agony. Dismas saw beyond the physical torment and perceived a deeper truth – that Jesus was innocent and divine.

In this life-altering revelation, Dismas found hope. Despite his own guilt and condemnation as a criminal, he turned towards Jesus with a plea for forgiveness. In his final moments, Dismas acknowledged his wrongdoing and humbly asked Jesus to remember him when he entered his kingdom.

Dismas’s story reminds us that no matter how dire our circumstances may seem or how far we have strayed from righteousness, there is always an opportunity for redemption. It is never too late to turn towards God and seek forgiveness.

Gestas remained hardened in his heart, failing to recognize Jesus’ true nature.

On the other side of Jesus hung Gestas, another criminal who shared the same fate as Dismas. However, unlike his counterpart, Gestas remained hardened in heart and failed to recognize the true nature of Jesus.

Gestas mocked and jeered at Jesus along with others who passed by. He joined in their taunts without realizing that he was mocking not just an innocent man but also the Son of God himself. Blinded by bitterness and anger, Gestas missed out on an opportunity for transformation and grace.

This stark contrast between Dismas and Gestas teaches us the importance of having an open heart and mind. It reminds us that true understanding comes from a willingness to see beyond our own prejudices and preconceived notions.

The criminals’ encounter with Jesus holds lessons for all Christians.

The story of the criminals on the cross next to Jesus is a powerful example of how divine encounters can shape lives and transform individuals. Their experiences serve as a reminder that no one is beyond the reach of God’s love and forgiveness, regardless of their past actions or circumstances.

For Christians, this story emphasizes the central message of the Gospel – that salvation is available to all who believe in Jesus Christ. It highlights the importance of recognizing our own need for forgiveness and redemption, just as Dismas did.

Moreover, it challenges us to examine our hearts and attitudes towards others. Are we quick to judge and condemn like Gestas, or do we extend grace and understanding? The encounter between Jesus and these two criminals invites us to reflect on our own responses when faced with those who may be marginalized or deemed unworthy by society.

Significance of Saint Dismas: Understanding his Story

Saint Dismas, also known as the “Good Thief,” holds a significant place in Christian teachings as an embodiment of repentance and redemption. Despite his criminal past, he found salvation through his unwavering faith in Jesus Christ. His story serves as a powerful reminder of God’s boundless mercy and willingness to forgive even those society deems unworthy.

Dismas’ tale is particularly compelling due to the circumstances surrounding his crucifixion alongside Jesus. As one of the two criminals crucified on either side of Christ, he had a unique opportunity to witness firsthand the profound love and forgiveness offered by the Son of God.

In many ways, Saint Dismas represents the ultimate example of a sinner transformed by grace. While hanging on the cross, he acknowledged his wrongdoings and recognized Jesus’ innocence, proclaiming, “We are punished justly, for we are getting what our deeds deserve. But this man has done nothing wrong” (Luke 23:41). This humble admission demonstrated not only remorse but also an understanding of Jesus’ divine nature.

Jesus responded to Dismas with compassion and assured him that they would be together in paradise that very day (Luke 23:43). This interaction highlights God’s unconditional love and willingness to extend salvation to anyone who genuinely repents.

The significance of Saint Dismas lies not only in his personal transformation but also in the message it conveys to believers. His story teaches us several important lessons:

  1. Repentance: Saint Dismas exemplifies true repentance—a sincere turning away from sin and a genuine desire for change. His acknowledgment of guilt serves as an inspiration for all individuals seeking forgiveness.
  2. Redemption: Despite leading a life filled with wrongdoing, Saint Dismas found redemption through his belief in Jesus Christ. This offers hope to those who may feel trapped in a cycle of sin, reminding them that it is never too late to seek God’s forgiveness and experience spiritual renewal.
  3. God’s Mercy: Saint Dismas’ story vividly illustrates God’s boundless mercy and grace. It serves as a reminder that no matter how grave our transgressions may be, God is always ready to extend His forgiveness and welcome us into His loving embrace.
  4. Inclusivity: Saint Dismas’ presence on the cross next to Jesus challenges societal norms and expectations. By granting salvation to a convicted criminal, Jesus demonstrates that no one is beyond redemption or unworthy of His love.

As believers reflect upon the significance of Saint Dismas, they are encouraged to emulate his example by acknowledging their own shortcomings, seeking repentance, and embracing the transformative power of Christ’s love. Through this lens, the story of Saint Dismas becomes an enduring symbol of hope, reminding us that regardless of our past mistakes or societal labels, we can find solace and redemption in the arms of our Savior.

So let us remember Saint Dismas as an inspiration—a testament to the immeasurable depths of God’s mercy and love for all humanity.

Influence in Pop Culture: The Legacy of the Thief on the Cross

The story of Dismas, the thief who was crucified alongside Jesus, has left an indelible mark on pop culture. Throughout history, this tale has inspired countless artistic representations in various forms of media, including literature, paintings, and films. These depictions have not only captured the imagination of audiences but have also served as a powerful testament to the thief’s transformation and the universal themes of redemption and grace.

Inspiring Artistic Representations

One cannot underestimate the impact that Dismas’ story has had on artistic expression. From ancient manuscripts to modern-day masterpieces, his presence on the cross has been depicted in a myriad of ways. In literature, authors have explored his journey with vivid descriptions and profound character development. One notable example is Victor Hugo’s “Les Misérables,” where Jean Valjean’s transformation mirrors that of Dismas as they both find salvation amidst their sins.

Paintings throughout history have also sought to capture the essence of this narrative. Artists such as Caravaggio and Salvador Dalí have skillfully portrayed Dismas’ encounter with Jesus on the cross, showcasing his repentance and ultimate acceptance into God’s kingdom. These visual representations serve as a reminder that even those deemed unworthy by society can find redemption through faith.

Portraying Transformation

Films have played a significant role in bringing Dismas’ story to life for audiences worldwide. Whether through epic biblical dramas or contemporary adaptations, filmmakers have sought to depict his transformation from a hardened criminal to a penitent believer. The portrayal of this metamorphosis resonates with viewers who are moved by stories of second chances and personal growth.

In movies like “The Robe” (1953) and “Barabbas” (1961), Dismas is portrayed as a complex character whose encounter with Jesus leads him to question his past actions and seek forgiveness. These cinematic interpretations allow audiences to witness the power of redemption and contemplate their own capacity for change.

Universal Themes of Redemption and Grace

The enduring popularity of Dismas’ narrative can be attributed to its exploration of universal themes. The story transcends religious boundaries, resonating with people from various backgrounds and beliefs. The thief’s journey serves as a powerful reminder that no one is beyond redemption, regardless of their past mistakes or societal labels.

Dismas’ story embodies the concept of grace, offering hope to those who may feel unworthy or lost. It reminds us that forgiveness is attainable and that transformation is possible even in the face of our darkest moments. This message has touched the hearts of countless individuals throughout history and continues to do so today.

Meaning and Relevance Today: Lessons from the Crucifixion

The crucifixion account offers lessons on forgiveness, compassion, and second chances.

The crucifixion of Jesus Christ is one of the most significant events in history, carrying profound meaning even in today’s world. At its core, this harrowing tale teaches us invaluable lessons about forgiveness, compassion, and the power of second chances. As we delve into the story of Jesus on the cross and reflect upon its relevance in our lives today, we are presented with an opportunity to grow as individuals and cultivate a more compassionate society.

One crucial aspect that emerges from the crucifixion narrative is the concept of forgiveness. Despite enduring unimaginable pain and suffering, Jesus exemplified boundless grace by forgiving those who persecuted Him. This act serves as a powerful reminder that forgiveness has the ability to heal wounds and foster reconciliation. In our own lives, this lesson encourages us to let go of grudges, embrace empathy, and extend forgiveness to those who have wronged us.

Another poignant lesson stems from the presence of Dismas – one of the criminals crucified alongside Jesus. Dismas’ story reminds us that it is never too late to seek redemption and turn our lives around. In his final moments on Earth, Dismas recognized his wrongdoing and humbly asked Jesus for mercy. Through this encounter, we learn that no matter how far we may have strayed or how flawed our past actions might be, there is always an opportunity for transformation and renewal.

This reflection on redemption leads us to consider our attitudes towards individuals whom society often deems outcasts or undeserving. Just as Jesus extended compassion towards Dismas in his darkest hour, we are prompted to examine whether we offer acceptance and understanding to those who may have made mistakes or faced adversity in their lives. The crucifixion challenges us not only to show empathy towards others but also to actively work towards creating a more inclusive and compassionate world.

In our fast-paced modern lives, it is easy to become consumed by the pressures of day-to-day existence. Yet, the crucifixion narrative compels us to pause and reflect on the deeper meaning of life. It encourages us to consider our purpose, values, and priorities. By contemplating the sacrifice made on that fateful day, we can find solace in knowing that there is a reason beyond ourselves – a reason rooted in love and grace.

Ultimately, the lessons derived from the crucifixion account have enduring relevance today. They inspire us to embrace forgiveness, extend compassion, seek redemption, and live with a sense of purpose. As we navigate the complexities of our own lives, may we remember the profound teachings embedded within this ancient tale and strive to embody its timeless wisdom every day.

Unraveling the Identity – Who Was on the Cross Next to Jesus

In conclusion, the identity of the individuals crucified alongside Jesus has been a topic of great interest and debate. Through historical accounts and biblical references, we have identified them as Dismas and Gestas. Dismas, often referred to as the penitent thief, had a profound encounter with Jesus on the cross, leading to his salvation. On the other hand, Gestas, known as the impenitent thief, remained defiant until his last breath.

The contrasting beliefs of these two criminals highlight the transformative power of faith in Jesus. While Dismas recognized his sins and sought redemption, Gestas rejected any notion of repentance. Their experiences with Jesus during their crucifixion provide a powerful testament to His message of forgiveness and salvation.

The significance of Saint Dismas lies in understanding his story as an example of divine mercy and grace. Despite a life filled with wrongdoing, he found redemption through his encounter with Jesus on that fateful day. This serves as a reminder that no one is beyond forgiveness or salvation.

The legacy of the thief on the cross has permeated popular culture through various artistic interpretations and depictions in literature, film, and music. The story continues to captivate audiences worldwide due to its timeless themes of redemption and hope.

Today, we can draw lessons from this pivotal moment in history. The crucifixion reminds us of our own need for introspection and repentance. It prompts us to reflect upon our actions and seek forgiveness for our shortcomings.

In considering who was on the cross next to Jesus, we are reminded that each individual’s choices have consequences – both in this life and beyond. It compels us to examine our beliefs and make conscious decisions about how we live our lives.

To truly understand this historical event’s impact on our lives today requires delving into its depths rather than merely scratching the surface. By exploring the stories of those crucified alongside Jesus, we gain insights that can guide us towards a more meaningful and purposeful existence.

In conclusion, the crucifixion narrative serves as a powerful reminder of the transformative power of faith, forgiveness, and redemption. It challenges us to examine our own lives and make choices that align with our values. Let us strive to emulate Saint Dismas’ journey towards salvation and find hope in the legacy left behind by the thief on the cross.


Is it historically accurate that there were two thieves crucified next to Jesus?

The presence of two criminals being crucified alongside Jesus is supported by historical accounts such as biblical texts and ancient writings.

Did both thieves have interactions with Jesus while on the cross?

Yes, according to biblical accounts, both criminals had encounters with Jesus while they were being crucified.

What was the outcome for each thief during their interaction with Jesus?

Dismas, also known as the penitent thief, repented and received forgiveness from Jesus. Gestas, or the impenitent thief, remained defiant until his death.

Why is Saint Dismas considered significant in Christian tradition?

Saint Dismas serves as an example of divine mercy and grace. His story highlights the possibility of redemption even for those who have led a life filled with wrongdoing.

How has the story of the thief on the cross influenced popular culture?

The story has been depicted in various forms of art, literature, film, and music throughout history. Its themes of redemption and hope continue to resonate with audiences worldwide.

What lessons can we learn from this historical event today?

The crucifixion narrative prompts us to reflect upon our actions and seek forgiveness for our shortcomings. It reminds us that no one is beyond redemption and encourages introspection in our own lives.

How can we apply the insights gained from this story in our daily lives?

By examining the choices made by those crucified alongside Jesus, we are encouraged to align our own actions with our values and seek a more meaningful existence. | Website | + posts

Ethan Davis, the founder of Jesus Salvation, transformed his life from hardship to faith after a significant encounter at age 32. After earning a Communications degree from Kansas State University, he established to help others towards salvation, sharing inspiring stories, scriptures, and prayers.